Friday, January 27, 2012

Lucretius: "The Nature of Things"

Introduction
by Richard Jenkyns

#Epicureanism--"a strict materialism, which denies the existence of anything magical, mysterious or transcendent."

[Greeks of the 8th to 5th centuries] discovered that fact is different from fiction and that history is different from myth, that theology and philosophy are different ways of talking about the world, and that each of these is different from natural science. #differentiation. 

The dominant tradition of Western philosophy descending from Socrates/Plato/Aristotle tells us to look inwards and work out the nature of reality within our own minds by a process of abstract reasoning. Epicurus held that natural science is the route to philosophical understanding, and his system...can be seen as a revival of an older tradition of Greek thought.  [See Empedocles below]

Epicurus begins not with abstract cogitation but with the external world:
  • All matter is made up of small indivisible particles - atoms- and that nothing exists but atoms and empty space. (includes mind and soul; death is simply a dissolution of atoms)
  • All events and processes are merely the effects of the movement of atoms. All existence is material; everything that exists is part of nature, and therefor there can be no supernatural realm. (No providential being/force)
  • No one can rationally pursue anything other than his own pleasure (but we should try to moderate them as far as our nature allows. (Not a flagrant hedonism)
  • All pleasures of the senses are inferior to abstract pleasures as friendship and philosophical contemplation. 
Epicureanism is often contrasted with Stoicism as indeed they were rival schools of thought (philosophic inquiry) through ancient Greece. But, both schools of thought assert that the mind of the wise man, enlightened by philosophy, is an impregnable citadel (both via negative ideals):
  • The goal of Stoicism was apatheia, or not feeling. 
  • The goal of Epicureanism was ataraxia, or not being disturbed. 
***According to Lucretius, everything that happens has the same essential cause. Every action, all creation and all destruction are alike the product of the push and pull of atoms 
Empedocles, another Greek (pre-Socratic?) believed that the universe was governed by an interplay between two forces: Love versus Strife. 
Love symbolized/associated with Venus/Aphrodite
Strife symbolized/associated with Mars/Ares
Both it would seems are necessary for the world to flourish, without Love there would be no coherence or continuity, without Strife no activity or new creation. So Love and Strife need to be in balance or harmony. 

Epicureanism/materialist philosophy appears to such the glory, wonder and mystery out of the world, and that as a philosophy of pleasure it was ignoble. 

     Lucretius' argument aims to show us that the teachings of Epicurus are true; the manner in which he puts that argument aims to show that they are also beautiful and lovable...by displaying as part of the beauty and diversity of the world the fact that everything has a fixed mother. [Lucretius'] metaphors of parenthood present everything that is, including ourselves, as part of a universal kinship. #cosmopolitan

"The great kinship of man with all mankind" - Marcus Aurelius
Meditations XII 23,26

     What Lucretius has done is to bring the doctrines of Epicurus a disposition of mind more characteristic of the rival Stoics. 

#Epicureanism: man can only rationally pursue our own pleasure. But the affection of parents and children for one another is a natural and instinctive pleasure, rooted in our animal being. Once we come to love the world as members of a family love one another, we can explain, in Epicurean terms, how it can be rational for us to care for creatures other than ourselves; and we have a new cause to accept, and even in a way to desire, our own deaths.
     Lucretius put the idea of salvation into the great poem...and finds safety within the individual, in the citadel of the soul. "The Nature of Things" is a didactic poem presented in a heroic manner. 


                                                                  Book I: Matter and Void
Superstition...Loomed over over mortal men, the first among them who dared raise
His Human eyes to her was Greek, the first man to withstand 
her. 
Neither the myths of gods, nor lightning bolts, nor threatening
thunder
Of heaven hindered him but, rather, all the more they fired
His mind's courage, so that he was the first man who desired
To break the close-barred gates of Nature down. The vital force
Of his intelligence prevailed, and he advanced his course
Far past the blazing bulwarks of the world, and roamed, the whole
Immeasurable Cosmos in his mind and in his soul. 
~~~~
One thing I am concerned about: you might, as you commence
Philosophy, decide you see impiety therein, 
And that the path you enter is the avenue to sin. 
More often, on the contrary, it is Religion breeds 
Wickedness and that has given rise to wrongful deeds...
~~~~
This dread, these shadows of the mind, must be swept away
Not by rays of the sun nor by the brilliant beams of day, 
But by observing Nature and her laws. And this will lay
The warp out for us - her first principle: that nothing's brought
Forth by any supernatural power out of naught. ...
Nothing can be made from nothing. 
~~~~
...Nature does not render anything to naught, 
But she instead  reduces everything that she has  wrought
Back to its eternal particles again [atoms]. 
~~~~
These particles perforce are indestructible. Therefore
Nothing can be reduced to nothing,...
~~~~
Thus things that seem to perish utterly, do not. See how
Nature refashions one thing from another, and won't allow
A birth unless it's midwived by another's death. 
~~~~
...Everything for which we have a name
Is either a quality of the two [matter or void], or a consequence of the same. 
A quality is what, without obliterating shock, 
Can never be separated and removed: as weight to rock. ...
Whatever comes and goes while natures stay unchanging, these
We rightly tend to term as 'consequences' or 'events'. 
Nor does Time exist in its own right. But there's a sense 
Derived from things themselves as to what's happened in the
past, 
And what is here and now, and what will come about at last. 
~~~~~
For any incident of history can be referred
To as a 'consequence' - of men or of where it occurred. ...
...done deeds have not separate entity 
The way  that matter does, nor can these deeds be said to be 
In the selfsame way that void exists. But we can rightly class
Them as consequences of matter and the place they came to pass. 
~~~~
Yet when it comes to fundamentals, they [Other philosophic schools of thought] meet their doom. 
These men were giants; when they stumble, they have far to fall: 
First, because they allow for motion with no void at all...[and]
...they don't provide
For any void to be mingled in their bodies. Second, because 
They set no limit to the division of bodies, and no pause 
To their decay, and utterly deny that there can be
A smallest particle;...
~~~~
In short, if the whole universe were fashioned from these four, 
and everything dissolved back to these elements once more, 
Why are they called the elements of things? Why not instead
Consider things their elements, and turn it on its head? 
For they are born of one another, ever changing hue
And changing their entire natures with one another too. 
~~~~
And thus you will gain knowledge, guided by a little labour, 
For one thing will illuminate the next, and blinding night
Won't steal your way; all secrets will be opened to your sight, 
One truth will illuminate another, as light kindles light.  

Book II : The Dance of Atoms
...it's sweet to know from what misfortunes you are free. ...
But there is nothing sweeter than to dwell in the towers that rise
On high, serene and fortified with teachings of the wise....
The skirmishing of wits, the scramble for renown, the fight, 
Each striving harder than the next, and struggling day and
night, 
To climb atop a heap of riches and lay claim to might. 
O miserable minds of men! O hearts that cannot see!
Beset by such great dangers and in such obscurity
You spend your lot in life! Don't you know it's plain
That all your nature yelps for is a body free from pain, 
And, to enjoy pleasure, a mind removed from fear and care? 
~~~~
In no way was the universe made by the power of God
For our sake, when the universe stands so profoundly flawed.  ...
This is the point I shall establish for you in due course
That nothing physical can lift itself by its own force, 
Nor can it drift up on its own, nor is it able to rise. 
~~~~
Another basic principle you need to have a sound
Understanding of: when bodies fall through empty space
Straight down, under their own weight, at a random time and 
place, 
They swerve a little. Just enough swerve for you to call 
It a change of course. Unless inclined to swerve, all things would fall
Right through the deep abyss like drops of rain...
Empty void cannot at any part or time withstand
Any object, but it must continually heed
Its nature and give way, so all things fall at equal speed,
Even though of differing weights, through the still void. 
~~~~
Again, if every motion is connected, and we hold
New motions that arise, arise in due course from the old, 
And atoms do not swerve a little and initiate
The kind of motion which in turn shatters the laws of fate, 
But leave effect to follow cause inexorably forever, 
Where does freewill come from that exists in every creature
The world over? Where do we get that freewill, wrenched away
From the fates, by which we proceeds to follow pleasure's
sway, 
So that we swerve our motions not at a designated spot
And fixed time, but the very place we will it in our thought? 
Without a doubt these motions have their beginning in the
whims
Of each, and from that Will these motions trickle into the limbs....
...it can follow that yearning of the mind, 
And therefore our motion has its impetus in Thought, we find, 
First arising from a whim of spirit, then travelling through
The flesh, and through the limbs. The same, however, is not true
When we lurch forward because we have received a mighty
shove
From someone else - it's clear then our whole mass is made to
move
And that our body's rushed ahead involuntarily 
Until our freewill curbs it back throughout our limbs...
...there is something in our chest can fight back and can stand
Against it, making the mass of matter turn at its command
Throughout our body, and when that mass is spurred ahead, can 
rein
It back into its place and settle it back down again.
Therefore, it's clear, the principle for atoms is the same: 
There must be something else besides just weights and blows to 
blame
Their movement on, from which our power of freewill arises. 
~~~~
For touch - yes the power of the gods!- touch is the key
To all our physical sensations, whether a feeling be
Triggered by a foreign substance worming its way within
Or something born inside the body itself inflict a pain;
~~~~
But those who claim
What feels is made from sensate elements, and that the same
Holds true for sensate elements, that these in turn derive
Their ability to feel from smaller things that are alive,
These people, by making atoms soft [must make them mortal too],
For all sensation's fastened to the flesh, to living tissue
Sinews and veins, and since we note that these are soft, we see
They must be of a substance subject to mortality.
~~~~
Therefore sense can't be an attribute
of atoms! Again, if living beings can only be allowed
To have sensations if in turn their atoms are endowed
With feeling, what of atoms which compose the human race?
~~~~
Nor does Death demolish anything so utterly
That it annihilates the very atoms of its matter;
It only makes the combination of the same atoms scatter.
From these it joins one particle with another--this is how
All things transform their shape and alter their colour, now
Receiving sensation, and in an instant, yielding it up again.
That's how you know how much depends on the configuration
Of atoms, how they're held together, and in what position,
What motions they impart to one another or receive,
And that's the reason you should not mistakenly believe
Atoms permanently retain those qualities we see
Sliding across the surfaces of things, both suddenly
Coming into being and of a sudden passing away.

...for what really matters,
What makes a world of difference, is the arrangement of the
letters [atoms]. ...for when you rearrange
Atoms, their order, shapes and motions, then you also change
What they compose.
~~~~
Since empty space is limitless on all sides and the amount
Of atoms meandering in the measureless universe, past count,
All flitting about in many different ways, endlessly hurled
In restless motion, it is most unlikely that this world,
This sky and rondure of the earth, was made the only one,
All all those atoms outside  of our world get nothing done;
Especially since this world is the product of Nature,
the happenstance
Of the seeds of things colliding into each other by pure chance
In every possible way, no aim in view, at random, blind,
Till sooner or later certain atoms suddenly combined...
~~~~
If you possess a firm grasp of these tenets, you will see
That Nature, rid of harsh taskmasters, all at once is free,
And everything she does, does on her own, so that gods play
No part.

From every direction, being drawn to what's the same;
Water adds to water, earth increase earth, and flame
Forges flame, air, air; till Nature, Maker of Things, brings each
To the zenith of its growth, the upper limit can reach...
But atoms must be entering in greater numbers still,
Until the object finally attains the pinnacle
Of growth. Then from that moment, little by little, over time,
Age breaks down the oak-strength and the vigour of its prime
And slide into decay...
It is therefore,
No wonder that things pass away, seeing how they become
Enfeebled by the ebb of atoms, and since all succumb
To outside blows.

Book III: Mortality and the Soul

Of mind and spirit, and toss that Dread of Death out on its ear, 
Since that's what stirs the lives of mortals into such turmoil
...For men say that illness or the loss of one's good name
Are more to be feared than death and the pit of Hell, and when
they claim
To know the essence of the soul is blood, or even air
If the fancy takes them, and our reason's something they can 
spare, 
Look to their actions--you will realize these things they crow
Are not beliefs they base on proven facts, but just for show. 
~~~~
The more harsh that their hardships are, the harder they hold on
To superstition. To truly take the measure of a man, 
You must observe him in the midst of trial and tribulation--
Then from the bottom of their hearts, men say what they believe: 
The mask is torn away, and what remains cannot deceive. 
~~~~
Compelled by an unfounded fear[of death], men, to evade such trouble,
Amass wealth by the blood of civil war, and they redouble
Their riches in their greed, heaping one murder on another.
Stone-hearted, they take pleasure in the sad death of a brother,
And are suspicious of the suppers served up by their kin.

Likewise, envy spring, from the self same fear, worries them thin...
Some fritter their lives away pursuing statues and a name.
Sometimes phobia of death can grip a man so tight
He comes to loathe his very life and looking on the light,
And in his mournful heart resolves to die by his own hand,
Oblivious this fear's source of what he cannot stand--
That this leads one to outrage honour, and to break ties
Of friendship, and in short overturn all loyalties.

[One can alleviate this fear] by  observing nature's laws and looking on her face.
First of all, I say that what is called the intellect
Or mind, the seat of reason and the rudder to direct
Our lives, is part and parcel of a man...
A state the Greeks call "Harmony", and they claim it is this
Phenomenon that animates and gives us consciousness,
Although the mind in no particular organ can be found.

...In order that you understand that spirit, for a start,
Likewise seated in the flesh, and the ability
To feel does not come from the body's parts in harmony: ...

Thus since the nature of mind and spirit, as we learn,
Is basically a part of a human being--then
The name of "harmony"-a word that should belong by rights
To the musicians,...

...mind and spirit are bound up with one another,
And that together they combine to form a single nature.
But what heads the whole body and reigns over it like a king
is Judgement, which we also name the "mind" or "understanding",
And this keep its abode in the mid-region of the chest.

The mind is thoughtful by itself, rejoices on its own
When nothing agitates the flesh and spirit. Just as pains
Afflict our head or eyes, while all the rest of us remains
Free from torment, so the mind alone may suffer hurt...
...But if fear
More strongly jolts the mind, the spirit feels it too, it's clear,
All through the frames. Hence the entire body sweats and pales, ...
IN short, men often physically collapse beneath the sway
Of mental dread. From this it's easy for anyone to discern
That spirit's yoked to mind- for struck by the mind's power, in
turn,
The spirit strikes and drives the  body forward. And we learn
By means of this same reasoning that the nature of the mind
And of the spirit is a physical one--...
Actions can be brought about only by means of touch.
And since what 'touches' must be material, isn't it true
That mind and spirit must be physical in nature too?
~~~~
...undertake to demonstrate to you what kind
Of material makes up the composition of the mind.
First, I assert the mind is delicate as it can be,...

...right when the peace of death has laid hold of a man
And mind and spirit retreat, inspect the body how you may,
You won't discover anything at all is taken away,
Neither in aspect nor in weight. For Death keeps the complete
Appearances of Life, except for vital sense and heat.
And therefore the whole soul consists of very tiny seeds...
For from the dying there escapes a slight breath mixed with heat,
while heat, in turn, must carry air along with it; for there
Is never any heat that is not also mixed with air.
Because heat's substance, being loose in texture, has to leave
Space for many seeds of air to travel through its weave.
This demonstrates the nature of the mind's at least threefold--
~~~~
Deep inside us; there is nothing deeper that abides
Within our bodies. It is the very soul of all the soul.
Just as, mingled in our limbs and bodies as a whole,
The force of mind and power of spirit lie hid from our view, ...
...this power with no name
Lies hidden, a sort of spirit of the spirit, and this same
Power furthermore holds its dominion over the frame.
~~~~
The mind too has a measure of hear--as when it seethes with ire, ...
...the mind possesses the tranquility of air,
When the heart's at peace, for instance, and the countenance is
fair.
~~~~
So too with men. Though education give them equal polish,
Still there are traces of their nature nothing can abolish.
Character flaws can't be uprooted--there will always be
One fellow who is more inclined to fall into fury. ...
The characters of men differ in many other respects
As well as those behaviors that the character affects...
Of inborn nature past the power of reason to erase,
That there is nothing that is fundamentally at odds
With living out our lives so they are worthy of the gods.
~~~~
This nature, then, is found throughout the body as a whole.
It is the body's sentinel, what keeps it sound. For soul
And body cling together with common roots, and so we see
The two cannot be wrenched apart without calamity. ...
So it is hard to extricate the spirit and the mind
From flesh with undoing everything that's left behind--
~~~~
...But do this favor for me just the same,
And yoke both of these concepts underneath a single name,
So that, say, when I speak of spirit, teaching that it dies,
Understand I am referring to the mind likewise,
Seeing that a single soul is formed out of their union.
~~~~
The living mind is mortal, since whoever wants to change
The mind or any other substance has to rearrange
The organization of its structure...
But what's immortal does not suffer any new
Arrangement of its members, nor can it be added to,
Neither can even one iota of it flow away. ...
Therefore, if the mind can sicken, or if it can be
Affected by a drug, that's proof of its mortality,...
~~~~
Flesh and spirit are both mortal--that much is decided,
Since both can be cut into many pieces and divided.

And if the nature of the soul's immortal, and it creeps
Into the body as we're born, why is it no one keeps
A memory of time before, why can't we bring to mind
The deeds that we have done, why do they leave no trace
behind? ...
Therefore you must admit that what it was has passed away,
And that which it is  presently has been created fresh.
~~~~
Even within our bodies a fixed and separate place for mind
And spirit to grow and dwell, all the more reason to deride
The thought they could arise and could endure somehow
outside.
Thus when the body is destroyed, you must admit the soul
Passes away, shredded through the body as a whole.
~~~~
Then Death is nothing to us; it concerns us not a jot,
Seeing we hold the mind is mortal....
So when the bond is put asunder between body and soul,
The two from which we are composed into a single whole,
Nothing can befall us, we who shall no longer be.
~~~~
...For when you cast
Your gaze back over the whole immeasurable span of ages
past, and consider matter's motions, a diversity so vast,
It's easy to believe that these same seeds of which we're made
In the here and now have in the past been frequently arrayed...
~~~~
Therefore, that Death is absolutely nothing we need to fear,
And that he who is not cannot be wretched or forlorn.
What can it matter to the man that he was even born
Once Deathless Death despoils him and his mortal life is shorn?
~~~~
For having as much of Life's rewards as you could reap,
You wither, but since you lust for what you don't have, and hold
cheap
What is at hand, Life, wasted and unfulfilled, slipped through
your fingers.
~~~~
And they, when life is through, shall follow you into the grave,
As those that came before, no less than you, wave after wave.
Thus one thing rises from another--it will never cease.
No one is given life to own; we all hold but a lease.
~~~~
There doesn't exist, as in the tale, a pitiful Tantalus
Who stands afraid, frozen to the spot from empty dread
Beneath a huge rock dangling in the air above his head.
But, rather, in life it's vain fear of the gods that hangs above
Mortals and downfalls of Chance they live in terror of.
~~~~
And Sisyphus exists in life, right here before our eyes:
The man consumed with seeking the accouterments of office
From the people, who always come back sad and beaten. To be
driven
To seek power--an illusion after all-- which is never given,
And undergo endless hard toil in striving for it still
This is the act of struggling to shove a stone uphill.
~~~~
...the Conscience fears its misdeeds, and it applies
Goads and floggings to itself, neither does it surmise,
Meanwhile, that there can be, to all its sufferings, an end,
Nor, at length, a final limit to its punishment,
So it dreads these same oppressions will grow weightier with
death,
Until, at last, the life of fools becomes a Hell on Earth.
~~~~
Thus in each way man is running from himself, yet still
Because he clings to that same self, although against his will,
And clearly can't escape from it, he loathes it; for he's ill
But doesn't grasp the cause of his disease....
It's his condition for all time--not for one hour--at stake,
The state in which all mortals should expect themselves to be
After death, for the remainder of eternity.
~~~~
The life  of mortals has a limit set to it, my friend.
Death has no loopholes. All of us must meet it in the end.
We go through the same motions in the same old place. No
measure
Of added life will ever could for us a novel pleasure.
True, while we lack that which we long for, it is an obsession,
But we will just crave something else once it's in our possession;
We are forever panting with an unquenched thirst for life.
No one knows what the years to come will bring--what joy or
strife
May lie in store for us, what outcome's looming in our lot.
But by adding on to life, we don't diminish by one jot
The length of death, nor are we able to subtract instead
Anything to abbreviate the time that we are dead.

Though you outlive as many generations as you will,
Nevertheless, Eternal Death is waiting for you still.
It is no shorter, that eternity that lies in store
For the man who with the setting Sun today will rise no more,
Than for the man who sun has set months, even years, before.

Book IV: The Senses
As for the fellow who asserts that "nothing can be known",
He [a sceptic] doesn't even know the fact, since he is the first to own
That he knows nothing!...
For sense he's never put faith in the sensory world before,
How does he even know what knowing is, or furthermore,
Not-knowing? What forms his notion of the false or of the true,
What evidence has proved the difference between the two?

You'll find the concept of the true is formed and has its root
In the senses, their testimony such that no one can refute.
For their must be a higher court to which you can appeal,
That on its own can disprove what is false by what is real.
Beside, on what except the senses can you more rely?
Shall reason, based on the senses' false witness, testify
Against those very senses out of which it's wholly sprung?
For if the senses are untrue, all reasoning is wrong....
Each sense has a function to perform,
A separate jurisdiction....
So one sense can't disprove that which another sense propounds.
Nor can these senses testify against themselves; they must
Be granted at all times an equal measure of trust.
Thus what they say is true, at any given time, is true.
~~~~
Lastly, in construction, if the carpenter's rule is bent,
Or if the square is warped on which we base our measurement,
Or if the level anywhere staggers off by even a jot,
All of the structure must be built on crooked lines, the lot
Ramshackle, tumble-down, walls leaning out or in, and all
Out of whack....
And all because it was betrayed
By faulty measurements when its foundation was being laid.
Likewise your reasoning concerning things is built askew
If founded on sensations that are off from plumb and true.
~~~~
That we behold him in the flesh, when we see in our dreams
A man fled from this life, and in the power of death and dust.
But there's a natural explanation: sense all sensation must
Be lying checked and listless in the limbs, it can't appeal
Against the witness of the False by evidence of the Real.
Besides, the Memory lying lax in sleep cannot avow
The fellow's long been in the grip of grave and death by now,
Whom the mind itself believes that it beholds alive and well.
~~~~
When the mind desires to picture something, why
Is it able to see it right away?-->

There exist many further divisions of Time lurking still
(The mind grasps this), and that is why at any time you will,
All images are ready to hand where you are--so fast
Is the speed at which they fly, and the supply of things so vast.
Thus, when one image passes away, the next that rises whose
A different stance, and so the first one seems to change its pose.
And since they are so find, the mind cannot perceive them clear
Unless it makes an effort. Thus, all of them disappear
Except the images the mind has geared itself to see.
Yes , the mind prepares itself, and looks expectantly
For the image that comes next. And therefore, come the image
does.
~~~~
For nothing is born just so that we can use it--in due course,
That which is born just so that we can use it--in due course,
That which is born creates its own use. 
~~~~
first, an image of walking comes into the mind,
And strikes it, as I've said before. Desire follows. You'll find
That no one starts to undertake a single act until
The mind has decided that it will.
Whatever thing the mind foresees, there is an image of.
And therefore when the mind rouses itself and wants to move
And walk, it stirs the whole force of the spirit scattered through...
Seeing that spirit and the mind so closely intermesh.
And spirit in turn prods the body, so all the mass of flesh
Is pushed ahead and moved little by little.
~~~~
[sleep/dream?]
First, sleep occurs when the spirits, force is scattered through the
frame--
So that some parts are cast abroad, and some parts of it keep
Within, crowded together more, retreating way down deep--
And only then do the limbs relax and slacken. For it's clear
This consciousness we have must come within the spirit's sphere.
So that when deep disrupts this consciousness, we must decide
The spirit has been scrambled up and expelled outside--
~~~~
[Love]
For though your love be absent, still the images remain,
the darling name of the beloved ringing in your ear.
~~~~
Nor does the man who gives the slip to Love lack for its fruit;
Rather, he enjoys it without penalty or pain:
Pleasures unalloyed not for the lovesick, but the sane.
~~~~
But Venus makes their suffering light
In the midst of love, and Pleasure, mingled in, curbs back the
bite.
For herein lies the hope: they think that they can quench the fire
By means of the same body that ignited their desire,
Something Nature contradicts with all her might. For love
Is unique: the more we have of it, the more it's not enough,
And the more calamitous desire sets the heart aflame.
~~~~
Nor is the power of a god to blame, nor Venus' dart,
When, from time to time, a plain girl steals somebody's heart.
Sometimes it is the woman herself who has achieved this feat;
By winning ways , and keeping her dress and person clean and neat,
She makes it easy to learn to live with her. And yet above
All this, it is a familiarity that leads to love.
For anything that's hammered by as blow, day after day,
However softly struck, at length is conquered and gives way.
Haven't you seen how drops of water falling, on their own
Have the power, over time, to wear their way through stone?

Book V: Cosmos and Civilization
#ataraxia
~~~~
And yet what dangers threaten if the mind is not washed clear, 
What battles we unwillingly invite into the heart!
How biting are desire's cares that worry man apart, 
How menacing the fears! And then consider Pride and Wrath
And Lust--and catastrophes which are their aftermath--
And Gluttony and Sloth. And he who's conquered all these, 
then
And banished them from the mind--not by the sword, but by the pen--
Shouldn't he be numbered with the gods and not with men? 
Especially because of the holy wisdom he would preach. 
~~~~
...For what could such immortal, blessed powers 
Stand to gain from any lavish gratitude of ours
That they should lift a finger for us? Or what new thing 
transpire
That could tempt beings so serene before to now desire
To change the life they had already? For if truth be told
Who revels in newfangledness is fed up with the old. ...
Who's never encountered any woe in all time hitherto, 
Who lives a life of bliss? If we had never been created--
What would have been the harm to us? Am I to be persuaded
Our life lay cringing in a mire of misery and dark 
Until the dawning of Creation lit us with its spark? 
[the universe was not created for our sake; Lucretius does not refute the existence of gods, but is adamant that they would have nothing to do with the realm of Nature.]
~~~~
Thus you can know that things require an ever-renewed supply
Of light, because wave after wave of the previous shafts die, 
And the only way things in the sun appear before our sight
Is they are ever replenished by that fountainhead of light. 
~~~~
...Strife stirring skirmishes up amongst them, and 
confusion, 
A melee of different intervals, of ways, connections, motion
Weights, combinations, blows--because, due to the manifold
Shapes and forms of atoms, not every group of them could
hold
Their configuration or make motions that could work together.
Then life began to join with like, parts started to dissever
From the chaos and draw the boundaries of the world, to 
organize
Its members, setting its mighty parts in place: the towering skies
Divided from the land, the open ocean set in turn
Separate and apart from where the aether's pure fires burn. 
~~~~
...Instead, 
It is the weight that comes from outside of ourselves that gall
When placed upon us, though often relatively very small. 
What matters in the end is what each has the power to do.
...
That though the soul is of a stuff as flimsy as can be, 
Yet it can shoulder that hefty bulk of our frame--because it
weaves
With the body into one whole cloth? And what is the force that 
heaves
The flesh up in a nimble spring, if not the spirit's might
Commanding the legs? 
Substance can be powerful when once it is combined
With a heavy mass, as the air joined the earth, and as you'll
find
Is true for us when flesh is teamed up with the power of the mind? 
~~~~
For Time changes the nature of the whole world, and one phase
Must be succeeded by the next; there is nothing that stays
The same. Everything flows. Nature makes everything alter, 
For as one thing grows feeble with old age and starts to falter, 
Another strengthens, emerging from obscurity. 
[All is transient.]
~~~~
They  [primordial man] could not look out for the common weal. There were not
then
Laws or customs governing  the ways men dealt with men;
But each man seized what plunder Chance put in his way. To
thrive,
Each learned to watch out for himself, his own will to survive.
...
What worried wretched man instead was, when asleep, he lay
At the mercy of the tribes of wild animals, easy prey.
At times he fled, evicted from his rocky dwelling, when
A wild boar from thing at the mouth or powerful lion burst in,
And in the dead of night, roused terror-stricken from his rest,
He yielded up his leafy pallet to the savage guest.

Back then the fate of an untimely death was no more rife
Than now, when men with moaning leave the sweet life of this life.
~~~~
Then after acquiring shelter, hides and fire, man and wife
Were joined [and lived beneath one roof, and learned to share a
life]
And realized it was their union that produced a child.
That was when the race of man first started to grow mild.
Then fire saw to it that their shivering bodies could not more
Endure the cold beneath the vault of heaven as before,
And Venus drained their powers, and the little ones, with ease,
Broke down the stubborn pride of parents with their coaxing
pleas.
Then neighbors began to form the bonds of friendship, with a 
will
Neither to be harmed themselves, nor do another ill, 
The safety of babes and womenfolk in one another's trust, 
And indicated by gesturing and grunting it was just 
For everyone to have mercy on the weak.  Without a doubt
Occasional infractions of the peace would come about
But the vast majority of people faithfully adhered 
To the pact, or else man would already have wholly
disappeared; 
Instead the human race has propagated to this day.
~~~~
In case you're wondering to yourself about how fire first came
To mankind, lightning brought it down to earth. This is the
flame
That is the source of all the other fire.
~~~~
Then those yo towered above the rest in intellect and bold
Imagination, day by day showed how to change the old
Manner of life with fire and with new ways of doing things. ...
Beauty was held in high esteem, and muscle won great praise.)
Then later on, wealth was invented; men discovered gold,
Which easily stole from  fair and strong all ran that they might
hold.

But if you'd steer your life by a philosophy that's true,
The way to be the wealthiest of men is to eschew
High living, and be contented in the mind--for there has never
Been a poverty of modest means. People yearned, however,
To be renowned and to be powerful--that way, they thought
They built their fortunes upon solid ground. But all for naught
...
Often Envy would blast them like a thunderbolt, to fell
Them with disdain and hurl them in the pit of hateful Hell.
And since, like lightning, Envy loves to singe the summits best,
And anything that raises itself up higher than the rest,
It is far preferable to live in peace and obey
Than to wish to reign in power and hold whole kingdoms in
your sway.
Let others wear themselves out all for nothing, sweating blood,
Battling their way along ambition's narrow road
Because their wisdom smacks of others' lips, and they pursue
Things that they only know at second-hand, rather than
through
Their own senses. For their way of life is just as wrong
Today as it will be tomorrow, and has been all along.
~~~~
For men are eager to trample underfoot what they before
Had held in too much awe. And mankind was reduced once
more
To chaos, the very bottom of the barrel, as each sought
Power and glory only for himself.
~~~~
And the fault, I think, lies chiefly within ourselves--because before
Animal pelts, the sons of the soil, with nothing on their back,
Were racked with cold, whereas we do not suffer from the lack
Of purple raiment worked with massive patterns in gold thread,
So long as we've a peasant cloak to shelter us instead.
Therefore the human race is ever labouring in vain,
And fretting the years away in bootless worries. For it's plain
Man doesn't realize that even having has its measure;
There's a point beyond which nothing can increase our real
pleasure.
And this is what has by degrees dragged Life so far from shore,
And stirred up from the very depths the tidal waves of War.

Seamanship and agriculture, law, fortifications,
Weaponry, clothing, roads, and all these sorts of innovations,
The prizes of life and absolutely everything that's fine--
Poetry, painting, statues cunningly wrought and made to shine--
By trial and error, and probing, restless intellect, day by day,
Step by step, these skills were taught to Man, feeling his way;
So incrementally Time brings all things within our sight,
And Reason lifts them up into the boundaries of light.
For men saw one thing after another clearly in their hears
Till they ascended to the very summit of the arts.

Book VI: Weather and the Earth
And blessed by the good name of sons, nevertheless, apart
In the privacy of their own homes, each was worried sick at
heart--
[#Anxiety]Against their will, these worries plagued their life, with no 
relenting, 
And made them burst out bitterly with cursing and lamenting--
He understood it was the vessel itself that was to blame, 
And that by means of its internal flaw, all things that came
Inside it from without, however sweet at first, went sour; 
Partly, he [Epicurus] saw, since it had holes and leaked, and by no power
Could anything fill it; partly since when anything was placed
Inside the vessel, it was 'corrupted' with an evil taste. 
And thus with his truth-telling words he washed the heart all 
clear, 
And set a limit to desire and an end to fear, 
And showed what was the highest good, towards which we all strain ,
And pointed out the route, that we, unswerving, might attain
The straight and narrow path; and showed what evils and what cares
Worry man at every turn and darken his affairs; 
~~~~
[Lucretius is sarcastic]...banish from yourself all thoughts unworthy of the gods
And alien to their peace, their power will often be at odds
With you and do you harm, that holy power that you slight; 
Not since their sublimity is outraged, and they thirst to smite
In wrathful, fierce revenge, but since you'll have it in your head
That tranquil beings, living in unruffled calm, instead
Seethe with great waves of wrath. You won't be able to draw 
near
The temples of the immortals with a heart that's free from fear. 
As for those images that wend their way to minds of men
From their holy bodies, and whose stamp declares their origin
From forms divine, you won't be in a fit state to receive
Them with a peaceful spirit. And it's easy to perceive
Right away the kind of life this leads to!
~~~~






Sunday, January 1, 2012

Seneca: "Letters from a Stoic"



                                    Introduction
#Stoicism; the most influential philosophy in the Graeco-Roman world; it had been developed and modified by a succession of thinkers...who showed some fair divergences. As a moral creed, it was based throughout on the following framework of belief: 
  • The world is a single great community in which all men are brothers
  • The world is ruled by a supreme providence which could be referred to by a variety of names: 
    • divine reason
    • divine will
    • creative reason
    • nature
    • the spirit (or purpose) of the universe
    • destiny
    • "the gods"
  • It is man's duty to live in conformity with the divine will by bring one's own life into alignment with 'nature's laws' and resigning one self completely and uncomplainingly to whatever fate may send him.
Only be living thus, and not setting too high a value on things which at any moment can be taken away... can he discover that true, unshakable peace and contentment to which ambition, luxury and...avarice are among the great obstacles. 

     Living in accordance with nature means...developing the inborn gift of reason which marks us off as different from the animal world. We are meant to set free or perfect this rational element, this particle of the universal reason, the 'divine spark' in our human makeup...it will show us that there's nothing either good or bad but thinking makes it so, discipline the pleasures and the passions, and generally subordinate the body and emotions to the mind and soul. 
     In this way we shall arrive at the true end of man, happiness, through having attained the one and only good thing in life, the ideal or goal called #arete in Greek and in Latin #virtus-->#Eudaemonia. 
     This, the summum bonum, or 'supreme ideal' is usually summarized in ancient philosophy as a combination of four qualities: 
  1. Wisdom (moral insight)
  2. Courage
  3. Self-control
  4. Justice
     Doing so enables a man to be self-sufficient #autarkeia, immune to suffering, superior to wounds and upsets of life...

     [Until Seneca] Stoicism had a forbidding aspect which went far to explain its failure to influence the masses. There was something fictional about the sapiens, the wise man or philosopher. This ideal figure seemed...to have somehow become perfect in some sudden transformation long ago; gradual self improvement was hardly discussed. The target it set seemed too high for ordinary men. It stifled and repressed ordinary emotions [to strive after the 4 qualities]. 
     Seneca's contribution to ancient philosophy lay in the humanization of this creed. 
     In statements of man's kinship with a beneficent, even loving, god and a belief in conscience as the divinely inspired 'inner light of the spirit', [Seneca's] attitudes are religions beyond anything in Roman state religion...the tendency of Stoicism was always to exalt man's importance in the universe rather than abase him before a higher authority...virtue was to be looked on as its own reward and vice its own punishment. 

Letter III
     ...If you are looking on anyone as a friend when you do not trust him as you trust yourself, you are making a grave mistake, and have failed to grasp sufficiently the full force of true friendship...After friendship is formed you must trust, but before that you must judge. 

Letter V
   The first thing philosophy promises us is the feeling of fellowship, of belonging to mankind and being members of a community. 
    Philosophy calls for simple living, not for doing penance...one's life should be a compromise between the ideal and the popular morality. 
    Limiting one's desires actually helps to cure one of fear: 
                                  
 "Cease to hope and you will cease to fear" -Hecato

     Letter VI
     ...[true friendship] which not hope nor fear concern for personal advantage ever sunders, that friendship in which people are ready to die...something that can never happen when mutual inclination draws two personalities together in a fellowship of desire for all that is honorable. 

Letter VII
     Retire into yourself as much as you can. Associate with people who are likely to improve you. Welcome those whom you are capable of improving. The process is a mutual one; men learn as they teach. 

Letter VIII
     Spurn everything that is added on by way of decoration and display by unnecessary labor. Reflect that nothing merits admiration except the spirit, the impressiveness of which prevents is from being impressed by anything. 

Letter IX
     The wise man is content with himself and therefore needs no friend...what Epicurus(#Epicureans) objects to in Stilbo and those (Cynics) who believe that the supreme ideal in life is a mind devoid of feeling 
or...impatiens...#apatheia
     The difference between the Epicurean and our own school is this: our wise man feels his troubles but overcomes them, while their wise man does not even feel them. 
     And this is what we mean when we say the wise man is self-content; he is so in the sense that he is able to do without friends, not that he desires to do without them...he bears  the loss of a friend with equanimity. 
     Great pleasure is to be found not only in keeping up an old and established friendship but also in beginning and building up a new one. There is the same difference between having gained a friend and actually gaining a friend as there is between a farmer harvesting and a farmer sowing...when his whole attention is absorbed in concentration on the work he is engaged on, a tremendous sense of satisfaction in created in him by his very absorption. 
     ...the wise man, self-sufficient as he is, still desires to have a friend if only for the purpose of practising friendship and ensuring that those talents are not idle. 
     ...if friendship is something to be sought out for its own sake, the self-contented man is entitled to pursue it. And how does he approach it? In the same way as he would any object of great beauty, not drawn by gain, not out of alarm at the vicissitudes of fortune. To procure friendship only for better and not worse is to rob it of all its dignity. 
     'The wise man is content with himself' --[the saying] applies him so far as happiness in life is concerned: for this all he needs is a rational and elevated spirit that treats fortune with disdain; for the actual business of living he needs a greater number of things. 
     Self-contented as ht is, then, he does not need friends - and wants as many of them as possible - but not to enable him to lead a happy life; this he will have even without friends. The supreme ideal does not call for any external aids. It is home-grown and wholly self-developed. 
     ...when the universe is dissolved and all the gods are merged in one, finding repose in himself, absorbed in his own thoughts. such...is the way of the wise man: he retires to his inner self, is his own company. 
     'All my possessions are with me' meaning...the qualities of a just, and good and enlightened character and indeed the very fact of not regarding as valuable anything that is capable of being taken away. 
     What difference does it make, after all, what your position in life is if you dislike it yourself?

Letter XI
     For no amount of wisdom enables one to do away with the physical or mental weaknesses that arise from natural causes; anything inborn or ingrained in one can by dint of practice be allayed but not overcome. #Schopenhauer's Will
    "We need to set our affections on some food man and keep him constantly before our eyes, so that we may live as if he were watching us and do everything as if he saw what we were doing." - Epicurus
     The personality should be provided with someone it can revere, someone whose influence can make even its private, inner life, more pure. Happy the man who improves other people not merely when he is in their presence but even when he is in their thoughts!
     There is a need...for someone as a standard against which our characters can measure themselves. Without a ruler to do it against you won't make the crooked straight. 

Letter XII
     If God adds the morrow we should accept it joyfully. The man who looks for the morrow without worrying over it knows a peaceful independence and a happiness beyond all others. 

Letter XV
     #wisdom
     Without wisdom the mind is sick, and the body itself...can only have the kind of strength that is found in persons of a demented or delirious state. So that this is the sort of healthiness you must make your principal concern...The greater load, moreover, on the body is crushing to the spirit and renders it less active. So keep the body within bounds as much as you can and make room for the spirit. 
     'The life of folly is empty of gratitude, full of anxiety: it is focused wholly on the future.' 
     [by folly]...means our own life precipitated by blind desire into activities that are likely to bring us harm and will certainly never bring us satisfaction--if they could ever satisfy us they would have done so by now...so be complete and independent of fortune. 

Letter XVI
     #philosophy
     It moulds and builds the personality, orders one's life, regulates one's conduct, shows one what one should do and what one should leave undone, sits at the helm and keeps one on the correct course as one is tossed about in perilous seas. 
     What helps can philosophy be to me is there is such a thing as fate? What help can it be if there is a deity controlling all? What help can it be if all is governed by chance? 
    It is philosophy that has the duty of protecting us. She will encourage us to submit to God with cheerfulness and to fortune with defiance; she will  show you how to follow God and bear what chance may send you. 

Letter XVIII
     For no one is worthy of a god unless he has paid no heed to riches. I am not...against possessing them, but I want to ensure that you possess them without tremors; and this you will only achieve in one way, by convincing yourself that you can live a happy life even without them, and by always regarding them as being on the point of vanishing. 
     #passion(anger)
     Anger carried to excess begets madness. It is a passion which flares up against all types of people. It is born of love as well as hate, and is as liable to arise in the course of sport or jesting as in affairs of a serious kind...the outcome of violent anger is a mental raving, and therefore anger is to be avoided not for the sake of moderation but for the sake of sanity. 

Letter XXVI
#Death
     Away with the world's opinion of you - it's always unsettled and divided. Away with the pursuits that have occupied the whole of your life - death is going to deliver the verdict in your case...It's only when breathing your last that the way you've spent your time will become apparent. I accept the terms and feel no dread of the coming judgment. 

Letter XXVII
     #character, #Eudaemonia
     Look around for some enduring good instead. And nothing answers this description except what the spirit discovers for itself within itself. A good character is the only guarantee of everlasting, carefree happiness. If you want to be successful you must devote all your waking hours and all your efforts to the task personally. This is not something that admits of delegation. It is a different branch of learning which has room for devilling. 
     A sound mind can neither be bought nor borrowed. And if it were for sale, I doubt whether you would find a buyer. And yet unsound ones are being purchased every day. 

Letter XXVIII
 A consciousness of wrongdoing is the first step to salvation. -Epicurus
     For a person who is not aware that he is doing anything wrong has no desire to be put right. You have to catch yourself doing it before you can reform. 

Letter XXXIII
     #appearances, #creativity
          You have to examine and consider it as a whole. There is a sequence about the creative process and a work of genius is a synthesis of its individual features from which nothing can be subtracted without disaster. 

**Letter XLI**
     God is near you, is with you, is inside you...there resides within us a divine spirit, which guards us and watches us in the evil and good that we do. As we treat him, so will he treat us. No man is good without God. 
     And if you come across a man who is never alarmed by dangers, never affected by cravings, happy in adversity, calm in the midst of storm, viewing mankind from a higher level and the gods from their own, is it not likely that a feeling will find its way into you of veneration  for him? Is it not  likely that you will say to yourself, "Here is a thing which is too great, too sublime for anyone to regard it as being in the same sort of category as that puny body it inhabits. Into that body there has descended a divine power. The soul that is elevated and well regulated, that passes through any experience as if it counted for comparatively little, that smiles at all the things we fear or pray for, is impelled by a force that comes from heaven. A thing of that soul's height cannot stand without the prop of a deity. 
     a soul possessed of greatness and holiness, which has been sent down into this world in order that we may gain a nearer knowledge of the divine, associates with us, but never loses contact with its source. On that source it depends; that is the direction in which its eyes turn, and the direction it strives to climb in; the manner in which it takes part in our affairs is that of a superior being. 
     No one should feel pride in anything that is not his own...Fruitfulness is the vine's peculiar virtue. 
     [Man's] spirit, and the perfection of his reason in that spirit [is like the fruitfulness of the vine]. For man is a rational animal. Man's ideal state is realized when he has fulfilled the purpose for which he was born. 

**Letter XLVIII**
     #Friendship, #philosophy
     Friendship creates a community of interest between us in everything. We have neither successes nor setbacks as individuals; our lives have a common end. No one can lead a happy life if he things only of himself and turns everything to his own purposes...The assiduous and scrupulous cultivation of this bond, which leads to our associating with our fellow-men and believes in the existence of a common law for all mankind, contributes more than anything else to the maintenance of that more intimate bond...friendship. 
     Shall I tell you what philosophy holds out to humanity? Counsel. 
     You've pledged to bring succour to the shipwrecked, to those in captivity, to the sick, the needy and men who are just placing their head's beneath the executioner's uplifted axe. 
     All mankind are stretching out their hands to you on every side. Lives that have been ruined, lives that are on the way to ruin are appealing for some help; it is to you that they look for hope and assistance. 
     For that is what philosophy has promised me - that she will make me God's equal. That's the invitation and that's what I've come for; be as good as your word. 
     Straightforwardness and simplicity are in keeping with goodness. 

**Letter LIII**
     I began to reflect how we are attended by an appalling forgetfulness of our weaknesses, even the physical ones which are continually bringing themselves to our notice, and much more so with those that are not only more serious but seemingly less apparent. 
     With afflictions of the spirit...the worse a person is, the less he feels it. 
     [Akin to a heavy, dreamless sleep]... the mind is to deep for consciousness of self...It's the person who's awakened who recounts his dream, and acknowledging one's failings is a sign of health. So let us rouse ourselves, so that we may be able to demonstrate our errors. But only philosophy will wake us; only philosophy will shake us out of that heavy sleep. 
     There is one thing in which the wise man actually surpasses any god: a god has nature to thank for his immunity from fear, while the wise man can thank his own efforts for this. Look at this for an achievement, to have all the frailty of a human being and all the freedom from care of a god. 

Letter LV
     [the philosopher] He alone knows how to live for himself; he is the one who knows the fundamental thing, how to live. 
     The fact that a person [the anti philosopher] is living for nobody does not mean that he is living for himself. Still, a persevering steadfastness of purpose counts for a lot, so that even inertia if stubbornly maintained may carry a certain weight. 
     The place one's in doesn't make any contribution to peace of mind: it's the spirit that makes everything agreeable to oneself. 
     Possession of a friend should be with the spirit: the spirit's never absent: it sees daily whoever it likes. 

Letter LVI
     The only true serenity is the one which represents the free development of a sound mind. 

Letter LXIII
#Sorrow, #Friendship
     When one has lost a fried one's eyes should be neither dry nor streaming. Tears, yes, there should be, but not lamentation. [As lamentation indicates] We are not being governed by our grief but parading it. 
     Inevitable as it is that the names of persons who were dear to us and are now lost should cause us a gnawing sort of pain when we think of them, that pain is not without a pleasure of its own. 
     "In the pleasure we find in the memory of departed friends there is a resemblance to the way in which certain bitter fruits are agreeable or the very acidity of an exceedingly old wind has its attraction. But after a certain interval all that pained us is obliterated and the enjoyment comes to us unalloyed." 
     Thinking of departed friends is to me something sweet and mellow. For when I had them with me it was with the feeling that I was going to lose them, and now that I have lost them I keep the feeling that I have them with me still. 
      If we have no other friends, we have done ourselves a greater injury than fortune has done us: She has deprived us of a single friend but we have deprived ourselves of every friend we have failed to make.
     You have buried someone you loved. Now look for someone else to love. It is better to make good the loss of a friend than to cry over him.  

Letter LXV
#Stoicism, #Platonism, #Creativity
     Stoic philosophers maintain there are two elements in the universe from which all things are derived: Cause and Matter. 
  • Matter lies inert and inactive, a substance unlimited potential but destined to remain idle if no one sets it in motion.
  • Cause (aka Reason-->God) turns Matter to whatever end it wishes and fashions it into a variety of different products. 
     There must be something out of which things come into being and something else by means of which things come into being. 
     Stoics believe there is only one cause - that which brings things into being. 
     Aristotle thinks the term 'cause'  can be used in 3 different manners. The first cause is matter - without it nothing can be brought into existence. The second is the craftsman, and the third is form/idios. 
     A "fourth cause" is the end in view of its making, for had this not existed the statue [an example] would not have been made at all. What is this end? It is what attracted the sculptor, what his goal was in creating it. 
     Plato adds a fifth cause to the model - what he calls the idea - this being what the sculptor had constantly before his eyes as he executed the intended work. [Vision]. 
     God has within himself models like this of everything in the universe, his mind embracing the designs and calculations for his projects; he is full of these images which Plato calls ideas; eternal, immutable, ever dynamic. So though human beings may perish, humanity in itself - the pattern on which every human being is molded - lasts on. 
   What is the end God has in view? Goodness. 
    Plato: 'what is the cause of God's creating the universe? He is good, and whoever is good can never be grudging with anything good; so he made it as good a world as it was in his power to make it. 
     What we are looking for at the moment is a primary and general cause. And this must be something elementary, since matter too is elementary. If we ask what cause is, surely the answer is creative reason, that is to say God. All those things which you have listed are not an array of individual causes, but dependent on as single one, the cause that actually creates. 
     The soul is in captivity unless philosophy comes to its rescue, bidding it breathe more freely in contemplation of nature. 
     When craftsmen engaged on some intricate piece of work which imposes a tiring strain on the eyes...they go out  into the open air and treat their eyes to free sunshine in some open space...[Likewise] the soul, shut away in this dim and dismal dwelling, as often as it can makes for the open and finds its relaxation in contemplating the natural universe. The wise man and devotee of philosophy is needless to say inseparable from his body, and yet he is detached from it so far as the best of part of his personality is concerned. 
     I am too great, was born to too great a destiny to be my body's slave[!]
     [the] body is all that is vulnerable about me: within this dwelling so liable to injury lives a spirit that is free. Never shall that flesh compel me to feel fear, never shall it drive me to any pretense unworthy of a good man; never shall I tell a lie out of consideration for this petty body. 
     We know that everything in the universe is composed of matter and God. God, encompassed within them, controls them all, they follow his leadership and guidance. Greater power and greater value reside in that which creates (ie, God) than in the matter on which God works. Well, the place which in this universe is occupied by God is in man the place of the spirit. 

Letter LXXVIII
#Friendship
     [Seneca's] advice to you: refuse to let the thought of death bother you: nothing is grim when we have escaped that fear. 
     What makes people who are morally unenlightened upset by the experience of physical distress is their failure to acquire the habit of contentment with the spirit. They have instead been preoccupied with the body. That is why a man of noble and enlightened character separates body from spirit and has just  as much to do with the former, the frail and complaining part of our nature, as is necessary and not more, and a lot to do with the better, the divine element. 
     Everything hangs on one's thinking. The love of power or money or luxurious living are not the only things which are guided by popular thinking...
     He should put his whole heart into the fight against them. If he gives way before them he will lose the battle; if he exerts himself against them he will win. What in fact most people do is pull down their heads what they should be holding up against...
     Let us too overcome all things, with our reward consisting not in any wreath or garland, not in trumpet-calls for silence for the ceremonial proclamation of our name, but in moral worth, in strength of spirit in a peace that is won for ever once in any contest fortune has been utterly defeated. 
     And so we shall as soon as we have learnt to distinguish the good things from the bad things in this world. Then and only then shall we stop being weary of living as well as scared of dying. For a life spent viewing all the variety, the majesty, the sublimity in things around us can never succumb to ennui: the feeling that one is tired of being, of existing, is usually the result of an idle and inactive leisure. 
     Cling tooth and nail to the following rule: not to give in to adversity, never to trust prosperity, and always take full note of fortune's habit of behaving just as she pleases, treating her as if she were actually going to do everything it is in her power to do. 

Letter LXXXIII
#reflection/meditation
     For what can be gained if something is concealed from man when nothing is barred from God? He is present in our minds, in attendance in the midst of our thoughts - although by attendance I did not mean to suggest that he is not at times absent from our thoughts. 
     What really ruins our characters is the fact that none of us looks back over his life. We think about what we are going to do, and only rarely of that, and fail to think about what we have done. 

Letter LXXXVIII
#philosophy, #wisdom, #virtue
     I have no respect for any study[liberal studies] whatsoever if its end is making of money. 
     ...there is only one liberal study that deserves the name - because it makes a person free - and that is the pursuit of wisdom. Its high ideals, its steadfastness and spirit make all other studies puerile and puny in comparison. 
     Well, if you are such an expert, measure a man's soul; tell me how large or how small it is. You can define a straight line; what use is that to you if you've no idea what straightness means in life? 
     So when it comes to character the liberal arts open the way to it rather than carry the personality all the way there...
     [liberal studies do not confer automatically through study]:
  • Bravery (treating with contempt thing ordinarily inspiring fear)
  • Loyalty (the most sacred quality that can be found in the human breast; never corrupted or driven to betray)
  • Self-Control (maintaining command of the pleasures, passions) 
  • Humanity (the trait which stops one from being arrogant toward one's fellows, or acrimony)
       In words, in actions, in emotions she [Humanity] reveals herself as kind and good-natured toward all. To her the troubles of anyone else are her own, and anything that benefits herself she welcomes because it will be of benefit to someone else. Do liberal studies inculcate these attitudes? No [not completely]. 
     Wisdom does not lie in books. Wisdom publishes not words but truths. 
     Virtue will not bring herself to enter the limited space we offer her; something of great size requires plenty of room. Let everything else be evicted, and your heart completely opened to her.  

Letter XC 
#philosophy    
      ...life is the gift of the immortal gods, but that living well is the gift of philosophy. 
     ...there is about wisdom a nobility and magnificence in the fact that she doesn't just fall to a person's lot, that each man owes her to his own efforts, that one doesn't go to anyone other than oneself to find her. 
     Philosophy has the single task of discovering  the truth about the divine and human worlds. The religious conscience, the sense of duty, justice and all the rest of the close-knit interdependent 'company of virtues', never leave her side. Philosophy has taught men to worship what is divine, to love what is human, telling us that with the gods belongs authority, and among human beings fellowship. That fellowship lasted for a long time intact, before men's greed[extravagance] broke society up. 
     ...that age before there existed architects or builders was a happy age. The squaring off of timbers, the accurate cutting of beams with a saw that travels along a marked out line, all these things came in with extravagance. 
     ...For men in a state of freedom had thatch for their shelter, while slavery dwells beneath marble and gold. 
     It was human ingenuity, not wisdom, which discovered all that. 
     [the hammer and tongs] were both invented by some individual of an alert, perceptive turn of mind, but not one with the qualities of greatness or of inspiration. 
     The wise man then followed a simple way of life...follow nature and you will feel no need of craftsmen. [Nature provided humanity with all necessities at the beginning, everything else is a distraction.]
     ...the bounds of nature, which set a limit to man's wants by relieving them only where there is necessity for such relief, have been lost sight of; to want simply what is enough nowadays suggests to people primitiveness and squalor. 
     Philosophy is far above all this; she does train men's hands: she is an instructress of men's minds. [you may ask] What philosophy has achieved? ...her voice is for peace, calling all mankind to live in harmony. And she is not the manufacturer of equipment for everyday essential purposes. 
     Philosophy takes as her aim that state of happiness/#eudaemonia. That is the direction she routes and guides us. She shows us what are real and what are only apparent evils. 
     ...the man who has no need of luck the luckiest man of all, and the man who is master of himself is the master of all. 
     ...avarice and luxury split human beings up and got them to abandon partnership for plunder. [Humans at that time lived at a time marked by [at least according to Seneca] stewardship, fellowship and common law/common property. Avarice and Luxury appears to have had a head start on the practice of philosophy and the result is that people tend to envy the baubles and status symbols of their neighbors rather than practice on their virtue.]
     nature does not five a man virtue: the process of becoming a good man is an art...[it] only comes to a character which has been thoroughly schooled and trained and brought to a pitch of perfection by unremitting practice. We are born for it, but not with it. And even in the best of people, until you cultivate it there is only the material for virtue, not virtue itself. 

***Letter CIV***
     Preserve a sense of proportion in your attitude to everything that pleases you...it is no more hard to bear a loss of those whom you love and regard as brightening your existence; for even if they do not grow again they are replaced. 
     If you wish to be stripped of your vices you must get right away from the examples others set of them. 
     For the only safe harbor in this life's tossing, troubled sea is to refuse to be bothered about what the future will bring and to stand ready and confident, squaring the breast to take without skulking or flinching whatever fortune hurls at us. 
     When she created us, nature endowed us with noble aspirations, and just as she gave certain animals ferocity, others timidity, others cunning, so to us she gave a spirit of exalted ambition; a spirit that takes us in search of a life of, not the greatest safety, but the greatest honor - a spirit very like the universe, which, so far as mortal footsteps may, it follows and adopts as a model.  It is self-assertive; it feels assured of honor and respect; it is master of all things; it is above all things; it should accordingly give into nothing; in nothing should it see a burden calculated to bow the shoulders of man. 
     You will see the capacity of man for hardship...[In Marcus Cato's life]
     We can show as spirited an attitude to just the same things if only we will choose to slip the yokes from our necks. But first we have to reject the life of pleasures...we need to look down on wealth, which is the wage of slavery. Gold and Silver and everything else that clutters our prosperous homes should be discarded. Freedom cannot be won without sacrifice. If you set a high value on her, everything else must be valued at little. 

Letter CV
     Now thing of the things that goad man into destroying man: 
  • Contempt (least important)
  • Hope
  • Envy
  • Hatred
     People should see that you not a person it is dangerous to offend: and with you reconciliation should be both easy and dependable...slave or free, there isn't a man who hasn't power enough to do you injury. To be feared is to fear: no one has been able to strike terror in others and at the same time enjoy peace of mind himself. 
     But nothing will help quite so much as just keeping quiet, talking to other people as little as possible, with yourself as much as possible. 
     Never to wrong others takes one a long way toward peace of mind. People who know self-restraint leads stormy and disordered lives, passing their time in a state of fear commensurate with the injuries they do to others. 

Letter CVII
     There are conditions of our existence which we cannot change. What we can do is adopt a noble spirit, such a spirit as befits a good man, so that we may bear up bravely under all that fortune sends us an bring us and bring our wills into tune with nature's; reversals, after all, are the means by which nature regulates this visible realm of hers..it is by means of opposites that eternity endures. 
Lead me, Master of the soaring Vault
Of Heaven, lead me, Father where you will. 
I stand here prompt and eager to obey. 
And ev'n suppose I were unwilling, still
I should attend you and know suffering,
 Dishonorable and grumbling, when I might
Have done so and been good as well. For Fate
The willing leads, the unwilling drags along. 
-Cleanthes

     Let fate find us ready and eager. Here [Cleanthes' prayer] is your noble spirit - the one which has put itself in the hands of fate; on the other side we have the puny degenerate spirit which struggles, and which sees nothing right in the way the universe is ordered, and would rather reform the gods than reform itself. 

Letter CVIII
     The subject you ask me about is one of those in which knowledge has no other justification than the knowledge itself. 
     'A person teaching and a person learning should have the same end in view: the improvement of the latter.' A person who goes to a philosopher should carry away with him something or other of value every day; he should return home a sounder man or at least more capable of becoming one. And he will: for the power of philosophy is such that she helps not only those who devote themselves to her but also those you come into contact with her. 
     [students] They are deeply affected by the words and become the persons they are told to be - or would if the impression on their mind were to last, if this magnificent enthusiasm were not immediately intercepted by that discourager of noble conduct, the crowd...
     When you see them in such a mood, keep at them and drive this home...having nothing to do with plays on words, syllogisms, sophistries and all the other toys of sterile intellectual cleverness. Speak out against the love of money. Speak out against extravagance...It is hardly believable how much can be achieved by this sort of speech, aimed at curing people, wholly directed to the good of the people listening. [#Theos] When the character i impressionable it is easily won over to a passion for what is noble and honorable; while a person's character is still malleable, and only corrupted to a mild degree, truth strikes deep if she finds the right kind of  advocate. 

Letter CXIV
     'People's speech matches their lives" - Greek proverb

     And just as the way in which each individual expresses himself resembles the way he acts, so in the case of a nation of declining morals and given over t luxury forms of expression...mirror the general behavior of that society...The spirit and the intellect cannot be of different hues. If the spirit is sound, if it is properly adjusted and has dignity and self-control, the intellect will be sober and sensible too. 
     Once a person's spirit has acquired the habit of disdaining what is customary and regards the usual as banal, it starts looking for novelty in its methods of expression as well.

Letter CXXII
     You needn't be surprised to discover so much individuality where vices are concerned. Vices are manifold, take countless different forms and are incapable of classification. Devotion to what is right is simple, devotion to what is wrong is complex and admits of infinite variations. It is the same with people's characters. 
     One of the causes of troubles that beset us is the way our lives are guided by the examples of others; instead of being set to rights by reason we are seduced by convention. 
     Once they have become general, mistaken ways acquire in our minds the status of correct ones. 
     How much better to pursue a straight course and eventually reach that destination where the things that are pleasant and the things that are honorable finally become, for you, the same. 
     No man is good by accident. Virtue has to be learnt. Pleasure is a poor and petty thing. No value should be set on it: it's something we share with dumb animals - the minutest, most insignificant creatures scutter after it. Glory's an empty, changeable thing, as fickle as the weather. Poverty's no evil to anyone unless he kicks against it. Death is not an evil. What is it then? The one law mankind has that is free from all discrimination.